Colts Theme Team Depth Chart

Last Updated: 12/11/25

Colts Theme Team

Build the best possible MUT 26 Colts theme team with the players listed below.

Looking for more options? You can filter by team chemistry and position in our database to see every player that's eligible for a specific theme team. Did we get something wrong? Let us know in the community Discord and we'll get it fixed as soon as possible.

Offense

Quarterback

OVR
93
Peyton
Manning
All-Madden
QB - Field General
OVR
93
Johnny
Unitas
Team Diamonds
QB - Field General
x3 Chem
OVR
91
Joe
Flacco
Redux
QB - Field General

Halfback

OVR
92
Jonathan
Taylor
Autumn
HB - Power Back
OVR
90
Eric
Dickerson
Collector's Series
HB - Power Back
OVR
75
Khalil
Herbert
Core
HB - Elusive Back
OVR
74
DJ
Giddens
Rookies
HB - Power Back

Fullback

None

Wide Receiver

OVR
95
Andre
Johnson
Ranked
WR - Physical
OVR
92
Adonai
Mitchell
BND
Blitz
WR - Playmaker
OVR
90
Michael
Pittman Jr
TOTW
WR - Physical
OVR
87
Laquon
Treadwell
TOTW
WR - Physical
OVR
87
Josh
Downs
Team Builders
WR - Slot
x2 Chem
OVR
84
Alec
Pierce
Most Feared
WR - Spectral Threat

Tight End

OVR
89
Tyler
Warren
Collector's Series
TE - Vertical Threat
Secondary:
FB
OVR
79
Jelani
Woods
Pregame Access
TE - Vertical Threat
OVR
76
Mo
Alie-Cox
Core
TE - Vertical Threat
OVR
73
Albert
Okwuegbunam
Core
TE - Vertical Threat

Left Tackle

OVR
93
Bernhard
Raimann
Stocking Stuffers
LT - Pass Protector
x3 Chem
Secondary:
RT
OVR
92
Chris
Hinton
Legends
LT - Power
Secondary:
RT
OVR
73
Blake
Freeland
Core
LT - Agile

Left Guard

OVR
90
Quenton
Nelson
Most Feared
LG - Agile Guardian
Secondary:
RG
OVR
73
Danny
Pinter
Core
LG - Agile
OVR
70
Josh
Sills
Core
LG - Power

Center

OVR
94
Ryan
Kelly
Zero Chill
C - Pass Protector
Secondary:
LG, RG
OVR
90
Tanor
Bortolini
Blitz
C - Agile
Secondary:
LG, RG
OVR
70
Wesley
French
Core
C - Power

Right Guard

OVR
83
Matt
Goncalves
Breakouts
RG - Power
Secondary:
LG
OVR
82
Matt
Pryor
Team Builders
RG - Power
Secondary:
LG
OVR
71
Dalton
Tucker
Core
RG - Power

Right Tackle

OVR
86
Braden
Smith
Unreal Moments
RT - Power
Secondary:
LT
OVR
75
Jalen
Travis
Rookies
RT - Power
OVR
74
Matt
Goncalves
Core
RT - Power

Special Teams

Kicker

OVR
94
Adam
Vinatieri
BND
Zero Chill
K - Accurate
OVR
87
Chase
McLaughlin
Core
K - Power

Punter

OVR
93
Rigoberto
Sanchez
Collector's Series
P - Power
OVR
85
Matt
Haack
BND
Unreal Moments
P - Power

Long Snapper

OVR
82
Luke
Rhodes
Core
LS - Power

Defense

Left Edge

OVR
83
JT
Tuimoloau
TOTW
LEDG - Power Rusher
Secondary:
REDG
OVR
77
Samson
Ebukam
Core
LEDG - Speed Rusher
OVR
71
Isaiah
Land
Core
LEDG - Speed Rusher

Defensive Tackle

OVR
90
Grover
Stewart
Zero Chill
DT - Nose Tackle
Secondary:
LEDG, REDG
OVR
90
DeForest
Buckner
TOTW
DT - Nose Tackle
Secondary:
LEDG, REDG
OVR
73
Neville
Gallimore
Core
DT - Speed Rusher
OVR
71
Tim
Smith
Rookies
DT - Nose Tackle
OVR
70
Adetomiwa
Adebawore
Core
DT - Nose Tackle

Right Edge

OVR
90
Al-Quadin
Muhammad
TOTW
REDG - Power Rusher
Secondary:
LEDG
OVR
85
Dwight
Freeney
Legends
REDG - Speed Rusher
Secondary:
LEDG
OVR
81
Denico
Autry
Autumn
REDG - Power Rusher
Secondary:
LEDG
OVR
78
Kwity
Paye
Core
REDG - Power Rusher

Strong-side Linebacker

OVR
92
Ted
Hendricks
All-Madden
SAM - Pass Coverage
Secondary:
MIKE, WILL
OVR
88
Cornelius
Bennett
Legends
SAM - Run Stopper
Secondary:
MIKE, WILL
OVR
76
Jacob
Phillips
Core
SAM - Run Stopper

Middle Linebacker

OVR
90
Bobby
Okereke
Most Feared
MIKE - Shadow Analyst
Secondary:
SAM, WILL
OVR
86
Zaire
Franklin
TOTW
MIKE - Run Stopper
Secondary:
SAM, WILL
OVR
77
Alexander
Johnson
Core
MIKE - Run Stopper
OVR
73
Segun
Olubi
Core
MIKE - Pass Coverage
OVR
70
Liam
Anderson
Core
MIKE - Pass Coverage

Weak-side Linebacker

OVR
85
Jaylon
Carlies
Team Builders
WILL - Pass Coverage
x2 Chem
Secondary:
MIKE, SAM
OVR
84
E.J.
Speed
Most Feared
WILL - Mystic Guard
Secondary:
MIKE, SAM
OVR
72
Cameron
McGrone
Core
WILL - Run Stopper

Cornerback

OVR
92
Charvarius
Ward
Autumn
CB - Zone
OVR
90
Sauce
Gardner
Most Feared
CB - Watcher
OVR
90
Mekhi
Blackmon
TOTW
CB - Slot
OVR
89
Antonio
Cromartie
Unreal Moments
CB - Man to Man
OVR
89
Isaiah
Rodgers Sr
Redux
CB - Zone
OVR
87
Tremon
Smith
Team Builders
CB - Zone

Free Safety

OVR
88
Nick
Cross
TOTW
FS - Zone
Secondary:
SS
OVR
86
Malik
Hooker
Campus Heroes
FS - Zone
Secondary:
SS
OVR
74
Rodney
Thomas II
Core
FS - Zone

Strong Safety

OVR
84
Camryn
Bynum
Game Time
SS - Run Support
Secondary:
FS
OVR
73
Daniel
Scott
Core
SS - Hybrid

Overall Ratings

Team
89.68
Offense
91.01
Defense
88.91
Special Teams
93.50

By default, we only show players that actually played for the Indianapolis Colts. If you want to see all players that can get Colts chemistry, select this option.