Qb1

rivjeter said:

I like Baker

The OP made it clear that he really doesn't want to know who QB1 is, just wants you to pick from the 4 he thinks are QB1.

whiplash13 said:

Has yet to fumble for me even when hit sticked.  I run very rarely with my QB so release is much more important to me.

If you like him that's cool but this year QB release not as vital  , plus there are other QBS with good releases and lastly Poe has the same release .

I have Reaper and he makes EVERY throw possible with ease and with DOTS lol

Massadolphin said:

If you like him that's cool but this year QB release not as vital  , plus there are other QBS with good releases and lastly Poe has the same release .

Your opinions and of course you are entitled to them, just as I am entitled to mine.  Mayfield's release is my favorite with Nix (Bryce) being 2nd and Josh Allen's(AR) as 3rd.  To me it also has to do with angles you get from the releases.  Mayfield and Nix(Bryce) seem to have much better success getting the ball over taller secondaries than Over the Top 2 or some of the other releases. Yes Poe had the same release but I am not an OOP fan and I didn't care for how he moved around the pocket, he felt clunky.  

Also, you include Bryce in your Poll but he doesn't have Tank or Truzz.  So based on what you have stated in this thread, he has all that speed but it's useless because he will fumble w/o a hit stick.

whiplash13 said:

Your opinions and of course you are entitled to them, just as I am entitled to mine.  Mayfield's release is my favorite with Nix (Bryce) being 2nd and Josh Allen's(AR) as 3rd.  To me it also has to do with angles you get from the releases.  Mayfield and Nix(Bryce) seem to have much better success getting the ball over taller secondaries than Over the Top 2 or some of the other releases. Yes Poe had the same release but I am not an OOP fan and I didn't care for how he moved around the pocket, he felt clunky.  

Also, you include Bryce in your Poll but he doesn't have Tank or Truzz.  So based on what you have stated in this thread, he has all that speed but it's useless because he will fumble w/o a hit stick.

He has DOTS

Massadolphin said:

He has DOTS

And Mayfield has Run and Gun.  I played with Reaper for a while and I see no difference between him w/ Dots and Mayfield w/o Dots.  The are both pinpoint in accuracy.

I am surprised that this is even

I'm still using AR his release is so quick doesn't need any velocity abilities and has built in tank

I've got Charlie Ward and couldn't be happier

whiplash13 said:

And Mayfield has Run and Gun.  I played with Reaper for a while and I see no difference between him w/ Dots and Mayfield w/o Dots.  The are both pinpoint in accuracy.

LOL , you said you said your a pocket passer  with then you say he has good because he has Run and Gun  , make it make sense . I think Baker is close to all the top 4-5 QBS  but because he has limited mobility the other ones edge him out . My opinion does not invalidate yours though , if Baker is your guy all good .

I feel most of the best QBs aren't on this list. Luck is too by far, than either Mayfield or ultimate, and then Vick Richardson and Ward. All of those guys have 96+ spd and can easily escape plenty. Personally using mcnabb on birds TT and he's a dog. Makes 99 percent of passes, and is fast enough to escape plenty. Seeing a lot of things on you have to run all the time with QB, but I think that's just user error on play calling. I rarely ever have to slip through the middle, and can't roll out because everyone good runs contain. If there sending enough to pressure me, than 9/10 times someone's open, and the 1/10 I can just slip out of pocket and throw away. No one is fast enough to beat abilities, and no one that I listed above is too slow to escape

Massadolphin said:

LOL , you said you said your a pocket passer  with then you say he has good because he has Run and Gun  , make it make sense . I think Baker is close to all the top 4-5 QBS  but because he has limited mobility the other ones edge him out . My opinion does not invalidate yours though , if Baker is your guy all good .

I said I don't run with my QB very often, that doesn't mean I don't move around the pocket or need to throw on the run to escape pressure.

salicagg said:

Nah, I’m cool (although my comment might have sounded a bit rough). By the way I’m using Charlie Ward for a while, he’s been solid with 99 speed and acceleration, fast running and releasing the ball, no complaints with his accuracy. Not the optimal AP cost, but has the benefit of fitting any theme team. I know he’s not a popular choice but I pulled him from a BND free pack and he does the trick for me.

I have him as well. What abilities are you running on him ?

Massadolphin said:

Qb1

NONE of the above -- where is/are:

1. Baker Mayfield -- best QB Release style in the entire game
2. Anthony Richardson -- second best QB Release style, with Tank, Truzz plus Inside + Sideline Deadeye results in a perfect blue pass on every single throw.
3. maybe Andrew Luck, but he's more of a gimmick card, primary use is Omaha 🧀🧀🧀
4. Caleb Williams -- for those Run N Gun folks

Thankfully there is no truly awful QB release this year, to the point where they were essentially unusable.  It's nice to have some player preference or personal choice, with a range of options to fit whatever play style YOU prefer.  For my money, i need the ball to come out quickly, so i tend to prioritize (some may say i overvalue QB Release) getting the ball out quickly, above almost everything else.  YMMV and that's okay.  Use whoever you prefer, who fits you team/scheme.