McFadden or Shaun Alexander?

Last Post
Posts: 29 |
25
#1

McFadden or Alexander, Im currently running with Shaun Alexander I like him and he breaks tackles, but when he does he usually ends up going backwards a few yards, still good overall. 
I haven’t played with McFadden, what’s y’all’s take on McFadden . I like to run the ball  and pass to RB every now and then. have any of you played with both?

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 866 |
155
#2

I love Mcfadden on my 40 Raiders tt

Reply with quote Send DM Report
OVR
93
Posts: 3330 |
3,555
#3

I really like having McFadden. If the run game ever gets fixed, he could be amazing.

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 297 |
170
#4

mcfadden is better. but i have shaun bnd so i sold my mcfadden

Reply with quote Send DM Report
OVR
91
Posts: 1370 |
1,174
#5

I had both and kept Mcfadden, I felt was a good amount better than Alexander, but I do have a Dolphins/Cowboys TT.  Zeke comes out today, but Mcfadden still looks better to me based on the stats we can see.

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Posts: 16 |
175
#6

The thing that worries me about McFadden is his low carry rating.  I fear he would fumble often, but I could be wrong.  I have Shawn and run Steamroller and Fall Forward on him for 2 AP total.  The dude picks up extra yards constantly.  Love him.

Reply with quote Send DM Report
Log in to join the conversation