is Nico better than Carmichael

I have both but I want to know if I can sell carmichael and am fine with Nico as my number 1.

If you have both shouldn't you be the one to tell us?

yelaraka said:

If you have both shouldn't you be the one to tell us?

There equal but who should I buy when I sell Carmichael.

MutGOAT42069 said:

There equal but who should I buy when I sell Carmichael.

whoever puts the ball in endzone better in your offense.

Personally I'd get a speedy shifty great route runner. I love the 95 SB Hines so I'd say the 99 Reels version. Best blocking WR in the game and a reliable short to mid field weapon. He also is great at returns even though it says he isn't. I can't find it in me to move on from his 95 it's been so reliable. If not him one of the blurr bros

MutGOAT42069 said:

I have both but I want to know if I can sell carmichael and am fine with Nico as my number 1.

Not even close. Carmichael is def better.

Daytripper517 said:

Not even close. Carmichael is def better.

Agree. He's a cheat code with that size. His RR stats are all higher too

Thank you

MutGOAT42069 said:

I have both but I want to know if I can sell carmichael and am fine with Nico as my number 1.

I'd say it depends on your style of offense. I play a lot of teams that have success with Carmichael running deeper routes, but I use Nico to run an offensive style with a lot of short and quick routes, which has also been quite succesfull with my run-heavy offense

MutGOAT42069 said:

I have both but I want to know if I can sell carmichael and am fine with Nico as my number 1.

I mean, i guess it depends what you value in the offense.  In my personal opinion, here's the top three receivers currently in-game, with a bit of a drop off after these top three:

1. Tyreek
2. Calvin
3. Randy

Perhaps Carmichael could be valued as number four, but the competition gets pretty fierce after the top three.  Prioritize things liek Jukebox and/or Evasive... or perhaps 0AP Route Tech, if you are struggling more with Man.  Tyreek feels liek a true end-game receiver, he's only lacking height, but i suspect his route running will continue to be top notch.

That being said, I used Nico as my primary Slot receiver for a minute and he was excellent.  I lucked out and pulled a Sun God, so i dropped him is as my primary Slot receiver, only due to the fact he got 6/6 AKA Crews "Y2K" chems which boosted him to 99 SPD, while also retaining the Slot Apprentice ability (for 0AP), although i no longer need that, as i've finally switched off Bo (QB).

Daytripper517 said:

Not even close. Carmichael is def better.

agree 100% - Carmichael is way ahead of Nico

Carmichael is clunky and his pads are goofy looking but otherwise he’s pretty good but for a better receiver it will cost you Scary Terry was amazing before I sold him. Calvin Johnson and Hester with the Token in him are cheaper options that I like better than Carmichael