Moderator Legend said:
The program was designed to encourage members making quality posts, but at a sustained level. It turned into many folks being very active when they were eligible to win again, and then disappearing. So it didn't really have the desired effect. We're thinking through new ways to reward member who are more consistent.
Just a thought, not sure of the feasability of this, but you could have "tiers" of users, where those who are consistent at posting, being helpful to the community, helping out the mods by reporting spam and stuff, and setting up a good example for other users have higher odds of winning GG points out of the forums. Again, not sure if this would be doable, just an idea.