More impactful in your team? Pick artists or Edge Threats

If for whatever reason....

you had to choose between having Pick artist on basically every DB on the field, or having double edge threats (with double or nothing) , which way are you going and why?

Edge threat

Neither.  Ed Reed with 2 pt Acrobat.   i only have the card below the full legend (90 i think)

Floyd with edge threat is OP but it also might be his ratings.  i never can tell with edge threat.

You only need 1 player with Edge threat and DON.  It a waste to have two since they would light up in the same situations.

I’m just getting started but Pick Artist has been very beneficial because my guys aren’t dropping Picks. Before my DBs were stone hand droppIng them feel like PA makes them pay for their mistakes a little more.

karmaklaw said:

You only need 1 player with Edge threat and DON.  It a waste to have two since they would light up in the same situations.

but that’s a good thing…

kaotikords said:

but that’s a good thing…

For the AP cost, could be good or bad the way I see it..., and well... that's why I'm asking y'all what you think.

TraeSkywalker said:

I’m just getting started but Pick Artist has been very beneficial because my guys aren’t dropping Picks. Before my DBs were stone hand droppIng them feel like PA makes them pay for their mistakes a little more.

Pick artist is NICE lol..

But getting to the QB in a couple of seconds without having to send heat is too...

karmaklaw said:

You only need 1 player with Edge threat and DON.  It a waste to have two since they would light up in the same situations.

I've been running this starting today and so far I haven't really missed the 2nd guy  but I also haven't come up against someone with double edge pros yet...

hidesertace said:

Neither.  Ed Reed with 2 pt Acrobat.   i only have the card below the full legend (90 i think)

Floyd with edge threat is OP but it also might be his ratings.  i never can tell with edge threat.

Just entertain the hypothetical ..  what are you picking?

kaotikords said:

but that’s a good thing…

True but also uses up all your AP.  What I meant was both player would light up and get to the qb and you would get a 0.5 sack from each player.   There for while not a bad thing I see it as a waste to get two free rusher when one is "good enough" and you can use the other AP elsewhere.  The only time I could see both was if we still had to deal with mobile qb rollouts, moving the pocket but that is not the case this year.

HorsesWannaHaveFun said:

I've been running this starting today and so far I haven't really missed the 2nd guy  but I also haven't come up against someone with double edge pros yet...

I disagree with the other poster but at the end of the day its all preference.  I dont think you need a second and would rather have more AP to play with.

HorsesWannaHaveFun said:

If for whatever reason....

you had to choose between having Pick artist on basically every DB on the field, or having double edge threats (with double or nothing) , which way are you going and why?

Definitely edge threat. Pick artist does nothing besides stop ur cb from getting dunked one. They just get better pick animations

Well when we get multiple people who have less cost for ET then thats going to be the way to go. Ive used PA except this year since ET has been OP and I never noticed anything. Maybe it stops the occasional play where the CB doesnt even try to jump which is sooooo fucking annoying, but I like more pressure. i have yet to try a double or nothing player yet or the D rally since I didnt realize seymour is sitll 500 fucking K and Im not spending 1/3 of my coins for him.

Its almost like do you use 6/7 points on your QB to set them up or have multiple in/our wr...