Talking about as a user defender or receiver - am i missing something here? I do not understand why at least half the time I am spamming Y my user just does nothing. For example, I have had WR Randy Moss "in the zone" with the Mossed XF multiple times, and multiple times threw deep balls to him, spamming Y, and he does not even attempt to catch the ball. I guess regardless of that X factor, this seems to be happening multiple times a game. I actually feel like it happens more on offense than defense. They just never go up to try to catch the ball.. It just seems like it has to fall in their lap.
On that note - does anyone know if you are supposed to hold Y in these moments? Or tap it repeatedly?