Good day everyone
I really do not like that when you go online to play people they tend to sit the entire game on one defense. Ea has a game that tries to mimic the NFL and I might be wrong but I have never seen a game where the entire game the defense has one play all game.
This one thing is in my opinion something that totally ruins the experience. So unrealistic and should be addressed
ItsmeD said:Good day everyone
I really do not like that when you go online to play people they tend to sit the entire game on one defense. Ea has a game that tries to mimic the NFL and I might be wrong but I have never seen a game where the entire game the defense has one play all game.
This one thing is in my opinion something that totally ruins the experience. So unrealistic and should be addressed
If you want realism go play offline. You can’t expect other people to not do something that works because it’s not “realistic”. It’s on you to get somebody to change defenses by beating it. Watch the video where the dolphins sent the same blitz 35 times vs the ravens because it worked. Finding your opponent’s weakness and exploiting it until they change something is the most realistic part of this game.
spanky1407 said:If you want realism go play offline. You can’t expect other people to not do something that works because it’s not “realistic”. It’s on you to get somebody to change defenses by beating it. Watch the video where the dolphins sent the same blitz 35 times vs the ravens because it worked. Finding your opponent’s weakness and exploiting it until they change something is the most realistic part of this game.
So which is it: He doesn’t know the right cheesy cheese-beater, or the game just doesn’t actually allow football tactics to play a role in stopping certain alignments and defender movements from making the offensive linemen look like idiots?
(It’s a little of both. In some ways the game plays smarter than it did last year, but there are still big holes in the AI that allow for some dumb things to consistently happen.)
spanky1407 said:If you want realism go play offline. You can’t expect other people to not do something that works because it’s not “realistic”. It’s on you to get somebody to change defenses by beating it. Watch the video where the dolphins sent the same blitz 35 times vs the ravens because it worked. Finding your opponent’s weakness and exploiting it until they change something is the most realistic part of this game.
Good day
Thanks for responding
I strongly disagree with your response. Here’s why , most people that sit in one type of D are using an exploit in the game, which is why they’re using that defense in the first place, so for the most part , it would be hard to try to find a defense in the short amount of time, these games are to beat it Also it is called “competitive” I don’t see what’s competitive about doing something like that.
Again it’s not realistic it never ever happens in any level of football let alone in the NFL and shouldn’t happen in the game.
ItsmeD said:Good day
Thanks for responding
I strongly disagree with your response. Here’s why , most people that sit in one type of D are using an exploit in the game, which is why they’re using that defense in the first place, so for the most part , it would be hard to try to find a defense in the short amount of time, these games are to beat it Also it is called “competitive” I don’t see what’s competitive about doing something like that.
Again it’s not realistic it never ever happens in any level of football let alone in the NFL and shouldn’t happen in the game.
he literally gave an example. the dolphins called a cover 0 (maybe it was cover 1?) man blitz over and over because the ravens didn’t beat it.
There isn’t currently any unbeatable thing in the game, there’s a counter available
Out of everything wrong with this game, people calling the same stuff is what makes it unrealistic to you ?
Thats one way to look at it.
ItsmeD said:Good day everyone
I really do not like that when you go online to play people they tend to sit the entire game on one defense. Ea has a game that tries to mimic the NFL and I might be wrong but I have never seen a game where the entire game the defense has one play all game.
This one thing is in my opinion something that totally ruins the experience. So unrealistic and should be addressed
There's a lot more than one thing making this game unrealistic.
For example, your safeties having worse pursuit angles than a 5 year old.
Or opposing WRs playing like a mix of prime OBJ, D-Hop, and Randy Moss every single time they are thrown a ball in double coverage.
Yes, running one play on offense/defense isn't realistic nor is it fun to play against. But at least it's stoppable.
As with most things...it is not the "thing" (in this case the game) it is the human in control...I will make zero excuses for EA...but...I would imagine it is very difficult to anticipate the way players will exploit or play. End of the day...everyone gets to play their way and I respect that...I get a choice in if I will participate in that (I will not)...so when I run into this issue (which is often) I thank them for their time and concede out to the next opponent. The quicker I get out...the quicker I find an enjoyable gaming experience.
von11 said:As with most things...it is not the "thing" (in this case the game) it is the human in control...I will make zero excuses for EA...but...I would imagine it is very difficult to anticipate the way players will exploit or play. End of the day...everyone gets to play their way and I respect that...I get a choice in if I will participate in that (I will not)...so when I run into this issue (which is often) I thank them for their time and concede out to the next opponent. The quicker I get out...the quicker I find an enjoyable gaming experience.
Good day
Thanks for your response
I don’t know. I just think it’s kind of unrealistic on defense to just sit in one formation the entire game, especially when you know that the game can’t work properly playing up against a exploited Defense and i’m assuming the company knows that they have issues and at the same time, they allow it knowing they are advertising cards in the marketplace and expect people to play the game and yet you have something like this, which to any person that plays football or once played football knows this is definitely something that is not in the game.
In a real football scenario the second you noticed someone is putting the same defense out there. You should be able to expose it. That’s not the case when playing this game.
ItsmeD said:Good day
Thanks for your response
I don’t know. I just think it’s kind of unrealistic on defense to just sit in one formation the entire game, especially when you know that the game can’t work properly playing up against a exploited Defense and i’m assuming the company knows that they have issues and at the same time, they allow it knowing they are advertising cards in the marketplace and expect people to play the game and yet you have something like this, which to any person that plays football or once played football knows this is definitely something that is not in the game.
In a real football scenario the second you noticed someone is putting the same defense out there. You should be able to expose it. That’s not the case when playing this game.
I’ve noticed a trend that all these “realism” dudes just suck at the game and consider coach suggestions no adjustments “real football “, and anything that beats their defense, stops their offense is “cheese”, or an exploit”. The real football scenario is the case when playing this game if someone runs the same defense all game I will score 40 or more points every time. Just because you want to run stock coach suggestions plays and make no adjustments doesn’t mean a defense that beats that is an “exploit”😂. Again in REAL FOOTBALL teams will do the same thing until the other team adjusts, in this game you are the other team adjust and make them change it up. Again watch the video of the dolphins in 2021 sending the same blitz all game because the ravens couldn’t stop it. If that isn’t real football I don’t know what is.
If the defense is staying in one defense all game, that means you are doing something wrong. You should make adjustments that beat whatever play they are sitting in. Why would someone switch their defense if you can't do anything against it?
spanky1407 said:I’ve noticed a trend that all these “realism” dudes just suck at the game and consider coach suggestions no adjustments “real football “, and anything that beats their defense, stops their offense is “cheese”, or an exploit”. The real football scenario is the case when playing this game if someone runs the same defense all game I will score 40 or more points every time. Just because you want to run stock coach suggestions plays and make no adjustments doesn’t mean a defense that beats that is an “exploit”😂. Again in REAL FOOTBALL teams will do the same thing until the other team adjusts, in this game you are the other team adjust and make them change it up. Again watch the video of the dolphins in 2021 sending the same blitz all game because the ravens couldn’t stop it. If that isn’t real football I don’t know what is.
That's because Lamar Jackson isn't an intelligent quarterback. He wins off of Roshambo play design.
Maybe the OP understands football better than Lamar, even if he lacks the athleticism to play in the NFL. That's what I get out of all this.
ItsmeD said:Good day everyone
I really do not like that when you go online to play people they tend to sit the entire game on one defense. Ea has a game that tries to mimic the NFL and I might be wrong but I have never seen a game where the entire game the defense has one play all game.
This one thing is in my opinion something that totally ruins the experience. So unrealistic and should be addressed
If you watched the Broncos vs. Seahawks superbowl about 10 years back, Seattle basically ran a rush 4 cover 3.
That was the defense they were in basically all year, and had a historically great team.
In all honesty though, not sure why anyone is playing Madden at this point...its not playable or even watchable 🤷♂️🤷♀️
spanky1407 said:I’ve noticed a trend that all these “realism” dudes just suck at the game and consider coach suggestions no adjustments “real football “, and anything that beats their defense, stops their offense is “cheese”, or an exploit”. The real football scenario is the case when playing this game if someone runs the same defense all game I will score 40 or more points every time. Just because you want to run stock coach suggestions plays and make no adjustments doesn’t mean a defense that beats that is an “exploit”😂. Again in REAL FOOTBALL teams will do the same thing until the other team adjusts, in this game you are the other team adjust and make them change it up. Again watch the video of the dolphins in 2021 sending the same blitz all game because the ravens couldn’t stop it. If that isn’t real football I don’t know what is.
Good day
in response to your comment I would say maybe these” realism dudes” are not good at the game because the game is not being played correctly and maybe the” realism, dudes” are trying to play the game the way the game actually is and finding out the hard way that they come across people that exploit the game. And yes, you might find one game out of the hundred NFL games that have been played. And maybe one in college to as well as high school I noticed someone had to go back as far as 10 years to show how a game showed that they were in one formation proving once again how rare it really is not the case in madden
a perfect example would be someone sitting in a defense with a 3 man line now anyone with any football knowledge would just run up the middle, with a 6 or 5 man front but not in this game there is an exploit that somehow one of the blockers doesn’t block which triggers a insta shed as they call it. This is just one of many things that happen when you’re exploiting the game.” Realism dudes.” Don’t want to play this way.
In thee end They don’t want to master exploiting The game and copying plays from a pro player who’s trying to win thousands of dollars in a tournament. they are just trying to play the way football is intended to be
ItsmeD said:Good day
in response to your comment I would say maybe these” realism dudes” are not good at the game because the game is not being played correctly and maybe the” realism, dudes” are trying to play the game the way the game actually is and finding out the hard way that they come across people that exploit the game. And yes, you might find one game out of the hundred NFL games that have been played. And maybe one in college to as well as high school I noticed someone had to go back as far as 10 years to show how a game showed that they were in one formation proving once again how rare it really is not the case in madden
a perfect example would be someone sitting in a defense with a 3 man line now anyone with any football knowledge would just run up the middle, with a 6 or 5 man front but not in this game there is an exploit that somehow one of the blockers doesn’t block which triggers a insta shed as they call it. This is just one of many things that happen when you’re exploiting the game.” Realism dudes.” Don’t want to play this way.
In thee end They don’t want to master exploiting The game and copying plays from a pro player who’s trying to win thousands of dollars in a tournament. they are just trying to play the way football is intended to be
Then play offline
