For the Colts, I would say it looks something like this:
QB: Peyton Manning, Andrew Luck, Johnny Unitas.
RB: Edgerrin James, Eric Dickerson, Marshall Faulk, Jonathan Taylor.
WR: Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne, TY Hilton, Raymond Berry, Bill Brooks, Micheal Pittman Jr.
TE: Dallas Clark, Jack Doyle, Marcus Pollard, John Mackey,
T: Tarik Glenn, Chris Hinton, Braden Smith, Anthony Castonzo, Ryan Diem.
G: Quenton Nelson, Will Fries, Ron Solt, Jake Scott.
C: Jeff Saturday, Ryan Kelly.
DE: Dwight Freeney, Robert Mathis, Gino Marchetti, Raheem Brock.
DT: Deforest Buckner, Grover Stewart, Joe Klecko, Booger McFarland.
ILB: Bobby Okereke, Gary Brackett, Cato June.
OLB: Shaquille Leonard, Ted Hendricks, Cornelius Bennett, Duane Bickett.
CB: Kenny Moore II, Vontae Davis, Stephon Gilmore, Kelvin Hayden, Nick Harper.
S: Bob Sanders, Antoine Bethea
FLEX: Nyheim Hines
K: Adam Vinatieri, Mike Vanderjagdt.
P: Pat McAfee, Hunter Smith