If you want to know which card is better... use both cards...

I get it that people ask opinions on which card to get,  wwhich is better,  etc... not just for McNair vs Stroud vs Perry... but all cards. 

And I appreciate that some people can't spend the coins on some of the LTDs..

But if you're asking because you legit may want to switch cards then you likely have the coins somewhere.... not everyone but lots of people do...

So just buy the card and try it out...Example, people saying Stroud's stack is better... he's QB1, etc.. easy to say if you're not going to even try McNair.... So people argue here who is better but most never even try both cards. 

I didn't think backyard QB was for me but after trying it,  it's insanely powerful.  McNair's release is like a rocket but smooth. He feels faster than his ratings.... and I was so sold on Stroud that I paid almost 3 for him... but after using one after the other ....I was wrong.

I don't necessarily have an issue with people asking which is better.... The ones that get me are the people who say QB-A is better than QB-B, and the QB-A card isnt even out yet!!! hahah... Or they say QB-A is better than QB-B, and the card has been out for like 10 minutes... Which clearly isnt enough time to evaluate a card....

It's the "Price predictions" ones that really get me... hahahha....

I agree...I started doing this a few months back with numerous different cards.  I would agree many may not have the coin to obtain and keep the card, but...I buy them in the morning...play with them all day and then sell them at night (card does me know good while I'm sleeping)...for the most part I get my "investment" back...sometimes I make a few coins and sometimes lose a few.  Not saying this is a coin making method, but it does allow me to "test drive" them.

It sure would be awkward if OP has repeatedly done what theyre complaining about

STRIKESHOT1 said:

It sure would be awkward if OP has repeatedly done what theyre complaining about

OP (me) has tried every top card in the game when they come out. So essentially I at least make comparisons based on actual gameplay...whether or not people agree with them is preference but I evaluate cards once I use them.

According to the binder sync, your lineup is worth 22 mil. Mine is worth 30. 

You're 72nd on the binder leaderboard. I'm 34th. So yes, I try every high end card in the game; that's how I base my review and comparison.

Martyr1968 said:

OP (me) has tried every top card in the game when they come out. So essentially I at least make comparisons based on actual gameplay...whether or not people agree with them is preference but I evaluate cards once I use them.

According to the binder sync, your lineup is worth 22 mil. Mine is worth 30. 

You're 72nd on the binder leaderboard. I'm 34th. So yes, I try every high end card in the game; that's how I base my review and comparison.

I said it'd be awkward if you've done it because you have done it, repeatedly:

https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/luck-or-lamar-trying-to-pick-one-36623/?post=288121#288121

https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/ghost-winfieldpacheco-need-1-more-safety-36700/?post=288631#288631

https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/better-pass-rushing-dt-buckner-or-carter-37000/?post=290892#290892

https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/gurley-orcj2k-37297/?post=293149#293149

You trying to flex(?) the worth of your team and/or binder leaderboard rank (lol?) is so completely irrelevant to this that it'd be comical if it weren't so sad.

I too was sold on Stroud one game with McNair throwing darts I never even tried to leave the pocket the trad 4 release is so perfect and I put up Stroud for auction I don’t have the ability to try every card I want still waiting to try JJ Watt and Gurley as well as CA Collectors Lamar, Gronk, OOP Vick RB etc but I have tried most of who I wanted to and I do like test driving my one complaint is I’m not a good timer of buying and selling I am almost always losing between 100 to 400 K when I try the more sought after LTDs

STRIKESHOT1 said:

I said it'd be awkward if you've done it because you have done it, repeatedly:

https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/luck-or-lamar-trying-to-pick-one-36623/?post=288121#288121

https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/ghost-winfieldpacheco-need-1-more-safety-36700/?post=288631#288631

https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/better-pass-rushing-dt-buckner-or-carter-37000/?post=290892#290892

https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/gurley-orcj2k-37297/?post=293149#293149

You trying to flex(?) the worth of your team and/or binder leaderboard rank (lol?) is so completely irrelevant to this that it'd be comical if it weren't so sad.

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

STRIKESHOT1 said:

I said it'd be awkward if you've done it because you have done it, repeatedly:

https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/luck-or-lamar-trying-to-pick-one-36623/?post=288121#288121

https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/ghost-winfieldpacheco-need-1-more-safety-36700/?post=288631#288631

https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/better-pass-rushing-dt-buckner-or-carter-37000/?post=290892#290892

https://www.mut.gg/forums/forum/mut-discussion-10/topic/gurley-orcj2k-37297/?post=293149#293149

You trying to flex(?) the worth of your team and/or binder leaderboard rank (lol?) is so completely irrelevant to this that it'd be comical if it weren't so sad.

No...what I've done is ask what people think.  I am flattered that you spent all the time to scroll through my posts and link to them...

But when it comes to comparing players I will talk about traits and abilities,  AP cost,  but even in those posts I've already tried the cards but still haven't decided....so I ask the forum..

But hey,  you keep watching my posts,  mmaybe you'll pick up something useful