After using most of the top QBs this Madden season...

I have used Stabler, Herbert, Vick, Allen, A-Rod, 99 Mahomes, Brady, Leon, etc...

In my personal experience, only 2 have had several "perfect" games - no missed throws, 100% completion % (12+ passes ).....Elway and Stabler

Brady has an honorable mention.

All of the other QBs have had those throws too frequently...the ones where you go "WTF was that!?"....Mahomes was nice for a while. Flacco was good at first but something happened with his card...Leon missed way too many throws. Allen sailed a few, Vick missed way too many throws and Herbert throws too many bad deep balls (which for Slinger 3 is surprising).

Just my opinion but Stabler is the best QB I have used all season with Elway and Brady as 2 and 3.

Martyr1968 said:

I have used Stabler, Herbert, Vick, Allen, A-Rod, 99 Mahomes, Brady, Leon, etc...

In my personal experience, only 2 have had several "perfect" games - no missed throws, 100% completion % (12+ passes ).....Elway and Stabler

Brady has an honorable mention.

All of the other QBs have had those throws too frequently...the ones where you go "WTF was that!?"....Mahomes was nice for a while. Flacco was good at first but something happened with his card...Leon missed way too many throws. Allen sailed a few, Vick missed way too many throws and Herbert throws too many bad deep balls (which for Slinger 3 is surprising).

Just my opinion but Stabler is the best QB I have used all season with Elway and Brady as 2 and 3.

I would concur with this. I doubt we get a better QB

I haven’t used all of the QB’s you listed but from the ones I’ve used and the ones I’ve played against I can pretty well agree with this list.

My only disagreement would be that I prefer Mahomes MVP over Brady. It might have more to do with my play style but Brady missed more mid range throws for me and Mahomes had better accuracy on the run.

Side note: Have you tried RG3‘s combine card? I’ve been wanting to try it but every time I buy it I end up selling it for a decent profit before I actually use the card, lol.