My TOTY Votes (if anyone cares)

beasty1202 said:

QB1: Burrow Or Allen, preferably Allen since he has a 92

RB1:  Jamaal Williams (Rushing TD Leader and just for fun)

WR1/2:Jamar Chase and Davante Adam’s or Diggs (WE DONT NEED HILL OR JEFFERSON)

TE1/2: Mark Andrews (We do not need Kittle or Kelce)

LT1: Trent Williams (Deserves it and we don’t need Thomas)

LG1: Joe Thuney (He’s a Chief but I got a Pats TT)

C1: Frank Ragnow (No need for Kelce or Humphre)

RG1: Zack Martin

RT1: Tristan Wirfs (Eagles don’t need another card and his current overall is a 90)

 MLB1: Fred Warner (DAWG)

LOLB1: Matthew Judon (DAWG/Pats TT)

ROLB1: Micah Parsons (DAWG)

RE1: Myles Garrett (Bosa does not need another card, 16 Sacks and outperformed Sweat)

DT1: Quinnen Williams (DAWG/12 Sacks, Jones does not need this card)

LE1: Brian Burns (12.5 Sacks, Crosby just got a 97 and give the panthers some charity)

SS1: Budda Baker (Needs the Upgrade most and eagles don’t need secondary)

FS1: Minkah Fitzpatrick (DAWG/6 Picks/96 Tackles, needs and upgrade and badger/Simmons both just got cards)

CB1: Jalen Ramsey/Gilmore (36 PDs, 4 Picks, currently a 92, or Gilmore for bias Pats TT)

CB2: Jaire Alexander (Locked up OPOY Jefferson in their matchup, GARDNER DOES NOT NEED A NEW CARD)

I don’t care enough for specialists, do whatever. 
Reminder that  the NFL Honors Cards do deserve to be TOTY, but they just got cards so it would be a waste. And Eagles/Chiefs TT is overpowered enough as it is, it would only make sense to balance it out.

as a seahawks fan i need that ryan neal instead of budda and i forgot Crosby just got a card I voted for him

beasty1202 said:

Great votes, I see a lot of the community agrees on the argument against players who got nominated yet they already have a 96+ but I think there’s too many kids who are going to vote for whichever players they know the name of or whoever will stack their cracked theme team, mainly chiefs and eagles theme team users. Hopefully EA votes outweigh those eagles and chiefs or honors players.

I mean can we blame them for stacking their theme teams? I voted for whoever got Steelers chems lol

I pray Ramsey get one

beasty1202 said:

QB1: Burrow Or Allen, preferably Allen since he has a 92

RB1:  Jamaal Williams (Rushing TD Leader and just for fun)

WR1/2:Jamar Chase and Davante Adam’s or Diggs (WE DONT NEED HILL OR JEFFERSON)

TE1/2: Mark Andrews (We do not need Kittle or Kelce)

LT1: Trent Williams (Deserves it and we don’t need Thomas)

LG1: Joe Thuney (He’s a Chief but I got a Pats TT)

C1: Frank Ragnow (No need for Kelce or Humphre)

RG1: Zack Martin

RT1: Tristan Wirfs (Eagles don’t need another card and his current overall is a 90)

 MLB1: Fred Warner (DAWG)

LOLB1: Matthew Judon (DAWG/Pats TT)

ROLB1: Micah Parsons (DAWG)

RE1: Myles Garrett (Bosa does not need another card, 16 Sacks and outperformed Sweat)

DT1: Quinnen Williams (DAWG/12 Sacks, Jones does not need this card)

LE1: Brian Burns (12.5 Sacks, Crosby just got a 97 and give the panthers some charity)

SS1: Budda Baker (Needs the Upgrade most and eagles don’t need secondary)

FS1: Minkah Fitzpatrick (DAWG/6 Picks/96 Tackles, needs and upgrade and badger/Simmons both just got cards)

CB1: Jalen Ramsey/Gilmore (36 PDs, 4 Picks, currently a 92, or Gilmore for bias Pats TT)

CB2: Jaire Alexander (Locked up OPOY Jefferson in their matchup, GARDNER DOES NOT NEED A NEW CARD)

I don’t care enough for specialists, do whatever. 
Reminder that  the NFL Honors Cards do deserve to be TOTY, but they just got cards so it would be a waste. And Eagles/Chiefs TT is overpowered enough as it is, it would only make sense to balance it out.

Mines was the same except corners I went with ps2, Jaire and for the 3rd in the specialist went with slay I love his aka and was good this year

Please vote for Chris Lindstrom. He is the only Falcon and the Falcons TT o-line goes: 93-82-84-90-89.

dametime03 said:

HB should be saquon barkley

Or josh jacobs

beasty1202 said:

QB1: Burrow Or Allen, preferably Allen since he has a 92

RB1:  Jamaal Williams (Rushing TD Leader and just for fun)

WR1/2:Jamar Chase and Davante Adam’s or Diggs (WE DONT NEED HILL OR JEFFERSON)

TE1/2: Mark Andrews (We do not need Kittle or Kelce)

LT1: Trent Williams (Deserves it and we don’t need Thomas)

LG1: Joe Thuney (He’s a Chief but I got a Pats TT)

C1: Frank Ragnow (No need for Kelce or Humphre)

RG1: Zack Martin

RT1: Tristan Wirfs (Eagles don’t need another card and his current overall is a 90)

 MLB1: Fred Warner (DAWG)

LOLB1: Matthew Judon (DAWG/Pats TT)

ROLB1: Micah Parsons (DAWG)

RE1: Myles Garrett (Bosa does not need another card, 16 Sacks and outperformed Sweat)

DT1: Quinnen Williams (DAWG/12 Sacks, Jones does not need this card)

LE1: Brian Burns (12.5 Sacks, Crosby just got a 97 and give the panthers some charity)

SS1: Budda Baker (Needs the Upgrade most and eagles don’t need secondary)

FS1: Minkah Fitzpatrick (DAWG/6 Picks/96 Tackles, needs and upgrade and badger/Simmons both just got cards)

CB1: Jalen Ramsey/Gilmore (36 PDs, 4 Picks, currently a 92, or Gilmore for bias Pats TT)

CB2: Jaire Alexander (Locked up OPOY Jefferson in their matchup, GARDNER DOES NOT NEED A NEW CARD)

I don’t care enough for specialists, do whatever. 
Reminder that  the NFL Honors Cards do deserve to be TOTY, but they just got cards so it would be a waste. And Eagles/Chiefs TT is overpowered enough as it is, it would only make sense to balance it out.

This is great for anyone that does not have a eagles theme team

Even if neither of my Dawgs wins I sure hope Micah Parsons wins cause he would be a nasty card and would be awesome for my scheme, my nickel coverages sometimes has the LE/RE peel off the line of scrimmage into coverage so I could use a pass-rush/coverage hybrid

Gent said:

I went with: 
QB: Joe Burrow
HB: Tony Pollard
WR1: Jamar Chase
WR2: Davante Adams
TE: Mark Andrews
LT: Trent Williams
LG: Joel Bitonio
C: Frank Ragnow
RG: Zack Martin
RT: Lane Johnson

CB1: Patrick Surtain II
CB2: Jaire Alexander
FS: Kevin Byard
SS: Derwin James
LOLB: Matthew Judon
ROLB: Micah Parsons
MLB: Lavonte David
DT: Derrick Brown
LE: Brian Burns
RE: Myles Garrett

Slot WR: Amon Ra St Brown
Slot CB: Tyson Campbell
Rush Defender: Cameron Hayward
Kick Returner: Jamal Agnew
FB: Kyle Juszczyk
3rd Down Back: Aaron Jones
P: Tommy Townsend
K: Daniel Carlson

Just mainly wanted to vote for guys who don't already have 96+ overalls. Ridiculous that EA put guys like Kelce, Gardner, Bosa, Crosby, Hurts, etc... on the list after they just got high end cards.

💯 I think CMC deserves a card though balled out and highest a 93. Scored in 15 of 18 games with 49ers.

Why doesn't anyone vote for Darrisaw hus best card is a gold and he is one of the best LT in the nfl

Gent said:

I went with: 
QB: Joe Burrow
HB: Tony Pollard
WR1: Jamar Chase
WR2: Davante Adams
TE: Mark Andrews
LT: Trent Williams
LG: Joel Bitonio
C: Frank Ragnow
RG: Zack Martin
RT: Lane Johnson

CB1: Patrick Surtain II
CB2: Jaire Alexander
FS: Kevin Byard
SS: Derwin James
LOLB: Matthew Judon
ROLB: Micah Parsons
MLB: Lavonte David
DT: Derrick Brown
LE: Brian Burns
RE: Myles Garrett

Slot WR: Amon Ra St Brown
Slot CB: Tyson Campbell
Rush Defender: Cameron Hayward
Kick Returner: Jamal Agnew
FB: Kyle Juszczyk
3rd Down Back: Aaron Jones
P: Tommy Townsend
K: Daniel Carlson

Just mainly wanted to vote for guys who don't already have 96+ overalls. Ridiculous that EA put guys like Kelce, Gardner, Bosa, Crosby, Hurts, etc... on the list after they just got high end cards.

really hoping Byard wins, he has been a top tier safety for years and never gets a great madden card, yes ik he’s on the short side of players but KOs fix height problems for me at least

PatPisntwashed said:

Why doesn't anyone vote for Darrisaw hus best card is a gold and he is one of the best LT in the nfl

he had a good season yeah, but you talking like hes way better than he actually is

That Derrick Brown NAT card at the beginning of M23 played so good. Definitely getting my vote

beasty1202 said:

QB1: Burrow Or Allen, preferably Allen since he has a 92

RB1:  Jamaal Williams (Rushing TD Leader and just for fun)

WR1/2:Jamar Chase and Davante Adam’s or Diggs (WE DONT NEED HILL OR JEFFERSON)

TE1/2: Mark Andrews (We do not need Kittle or Kelce)

LT1: Trent Williams (Deserves it and we don’t need Thomas)

LG1: Joe Thuney (He’s a Chief but I got a Pats TT)

C1: Frank Ragnow (No need for Kelce or Humphre)

RG1: Zack Martin

RT1: Tristan Wirfs (Eagles don’t need another card and his current overall is a 90)

 MLB1: Fred Warner (DAWG)

LOLB1: Matthew Judon (DAWG/Pats TT)

ROLB1: Micah Parsons (DAWG)

RE1: Myles Garrett (Bosa does not need another card, 16 Sacks and outperformed Sweat)

DT1: Quinnen Williams (DAWG/12 Sacks, Jones does not need this card)

LE1: Brian Burns (12.5 Sacks, Crosby just got a 97 and give the panthers some charity)

SS1: Budda Baker (Needs the Upgrade most and eagles don’t need secondary)

FS1: Minkah Fitzpatrick (DAWG/6 Picks/96 Tackles, needs and upgrade and badger/Simmons both just got cards)

CB1: Jalen Ramsey/Gilmore (36 PDs, 4 Picks, currently a 92, or Gilmore for bias Pats TT)

CB2: Jaire Alexander (Locked up OPOY Jefferson in their matchup, GARDNER DOES NOT NEED A NEW CARD)

I don’t care enough for specialists, do whatever. 
Reminder that  the NFL Honors Cards do deserve to be TOTY, but they just got cards so it would be a waste. And Eagles/Chiefs TT is overpowered enough as it is, it would only make sense to balance it out.

Thank you for voting Budda he needs a card his been disrespected by ea forever also my picks were almost the same as yours except I didn’t go Fred Warner cuz he has a 96