Defensive abilities glitch need help

This same scenario basically happened to me -- it's incredibly buggy, but try to create a new team, or perhaps clone your existing line up and attempt to basically start fresh.  The game possibly/probably thinks there's something off with your lineup.  I get so many random errors it can be difficult to troubleshoot.  I believe i ultimately "resolved" (at least temporarily) the issue by eliminating ALL players and starting fresh adding their X-factors and regular abilities.

Hope that helps.  Also on PS5.