Still on this zone kick but may be going back in near future to man
sensicough
Posts: 718 |
50
SlowAndSteady
Posts: 2909 |
315
sensicough said:I have seen Carmichael just stand there picking his nose, scratching his butt and dancing around to some imaginary song while allowing WRs to just burn him up. Calvin hasn’t done this once. I’ve had as many INTs with Calvin as I have anyone ever in this game. Suppose it depends on scheme but I’ve sold Carmichael twice and I’m scared to death to put him in my lineup again
This has been similar to my experience. Calvin has been really good at CB and deep SS. Carmichael hasn’t really done anything for me. I’ve had him at CB1, slot CB, and deep SS. Carmichael just doesn’t react like he should, Big Play Slay has played way better than Carmichael it’s just hard for me to drop Harold because he’s so tall.
bcolby20
Posts: 759 |
648
I have both and don't have a bad thing to say about either. I run Calvin at cb1 and Carmichael at cb2 with deion in the slot and it's nasty for me.
Last edited by
bcolby20
- ,
edited 1
time in total.
heffitos
Posts: 177 |
15
bcolby20 said:I have both and don't have a bad thing to say about either. I run Calvin at cb1 and Carmichael at cb2 with deion in the slot and it's nasty for me.
sweet, thanks!
Robc955
Posts: 261 |
2
Haven’t tried calvin but Carmichael may never leave my lineup
heffitos
Posts: 177 |
15
SebSeb88 said:If you do keep Deion I’d put him there. He plays pretty well for me there. If you QS him put Haynes in the slot.
Played for a little with Haynes in the slot, did okay. He got cooked a quite few times. Switched him out for Deion and Deion just went crazy. Definitely the right move.
heffitos
Posts: 177 |
15
SlowAndSteady said:This has been similar to my experience. Calvin has been really good at CB and deep SS. Carmichael hasn’t really done anything for me. I’ve had him at CB1, slot CB, and deep SS. Carmichael just doesn’t react like he should, Big Play Slay has played way better than Carmichael it’s just hard for me to drop Harold because he’s so tall.
Member of the Week! I’m so honored lol. What type of scheme do run? From what I’ve heard/read, Carmichael is good in man but struggles in zone. I’d love to hear your insight.
heffitos
Posts: 177 |
15
I moved Carmichael to CB1 and he’s been pretty solid. Put Deion in the slot and he’s been doing great (I run man btw). Thanks for the advice everybody!
SlowAndSteady
Posts: 2909 |
315
heffitos said:Member of the Week! I’m so honored lol. What type of scheme do run? From what I’ve heard/read, Carmichael is good in man but struggles in zone. I’d love to hear your insight.
I run 99% zone so maybe that’s why he hasn’t done anything for me. I‘m going to run through some H2H this morning and see if anything good happens with him.
SebSeb88
Posts: 1253 |
110
heffitos said:Played for a little with Haynes in the slot, did okay. He got cooked a quite few times. Switched him out for Deion and Deion just went crazy. Definitely the right move.
Sounds good. Hopefully he keeps playing that way!
heffitos
Posts: 177 |
15
SlowAndSteady said:I run 99% zone so maybe that’s why he hasn’t done anything for me. I‘m going to run through some H2H this morning and see if anything good happens with him.
Sweet! Let me know how he does!
heffitos
Posts: 177 |
15
SebSeb88 said:Sounds good. Hopefully he keeps playing that way!
Yeah for sure! Thanks so much for the advice!
SlowAndSteady
Posts: 2909 |
315
heffitos said:Sweet! Let me know how he does!
I played through 4 H2H this morning and the only thing notable that he did was drop an easy INT 🤦♂️
I think the answer is Megatron CB in Zone and Carmichael in Man.
heffitos
Posts: 177 |
15
SlowAndSteady said:I played through 4 H2H this morning and the only thing notable that he did was drop an easy INT 🤦♂️
I think the answer is Megatron CB in Zone and Carmichael in Man.
Lol. Good to know, I just played a few and Carmichael got a clutch pick and did pretty solid in my man scheme. So that sounds like the consensus.
SlowAndSteady
Posts: 2909 |
315
heffitos said:Lol. Good to know, I just played a few and Carmichael got a clutch pick and did pretty solid in my man scheme. So that sounds like the consensus.
Well now I ran through H2H this afternoon, 8-0, won another Super Bowl. The last 3 games Carmichael got at least one INT in each. I think two were pick 6’s. Finally found a spot for him at CB2.